News Summary
The San Diego County Planning Commission voted against a proposed sand mine in El Cajon, a significant win for local residents. After a lengthy 4.5-hour hearing, concerns over health risks and environmental impact led to a tie vote, effectively halting the project. Opponents highlighted issues related to nearby residential areas, schools, and potential harm to the Kumeyaay Tribe’s burial grounds. While supporters argue for local jobs and reduced housing costs, the decision marks a pivotal moment in the ongoing conflict between industrial development and community welfare.
El Cajon, California – The San Diego County Planning Commission has voted against a proposed large-scale sand mine project in unincorporated El Cajon, marking a significant victory for local residents who have opposed the plan for seven years. The commission reached a tie with a 3-3 vote, effectively blocking the project from advancing further.
The lengthy 4.5-hour hearing drew considerable input from residents and community members, following several town hall meetings and postponed votes earlier in the year. Most speakers at the commission meeting expressed concerns regarding potential health risks associated with the mine, particularly its adverse effects on soil and air quality in the neighborhood.
Commissioner Yolanda Calvo emphasized her apprehensions about placing industrial operations amid residential zones. The proposed mine would have occupied a site previously home to a golf course until its closure in 2017, located in the Valle De Oro area, between Willow Glen Drive and Ivanhoe Ranch Road. The locality is primarily residential, with approximately 150 homes situated nearby.
In response to the decision, a spokesperson for the landowner indicated plans to appeal the ruling to the Board of Supervisors, suggesting that proponents of the project, including local carpenters and construction groups, believe it could create jobs and decrease housing costs by sourcing sand locally.
However, county staff recommended denial of the project, citing harmful effects on the character of the neighborhood. Opponents of the mine highlighted specific health concerns, including the vulnerability of residents with recent medical conditions, as well as the proximity of schools to potential dust generated by mining activities. Additional worries involved the possibility of excavating burial grounds significant to the Kumeyaay Tribe.
The proposed sand extraction was intended to last a decade, with an option for extension, and could have resulted in an estimated 23 truck trips per hour. Opponents highlighted that these frequent trips posed risks concerning safety and environmental degradation.
While supporters defended the project by asserting that concerns about its impact were exaggerated, they acknowledged minimal noise and dust would be generated but insisted it would not pose significant harm. They argued that the region would remain dependent on imported sand, leading to complications with supply chain disruptions if the mining project did not proceed.
The hearing’s outcomes reflected a narrow divide among commissioners. Ronald Ashman, Michael Edwards, and Colton Sudberry voted in favor of the proposal, while Molly Weber and David Pallinger opposed it. Additionally, Supervisor Monica Montgomery Steppe publicly stated she would vote against the project should it come before the Board of Supervisors, further complicating its potential future.
As local residents continue to mobilize against the mine, organizations like StopCottonwoodSandMine.org are actively raising funds to challenge the proposal and further amplify community concerns regarding health and safety. The decision by the planning commission marks a pivotal moment in a long-standing dispute between residents advocating for their neighborhood’s health and developers seeking economic opportunities.
Overall, this decision brings to light the ongoing struggle between industrial development and community welfare, as well as the importance of considering public health in regional planning efforts.
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
HERE Resources
Chalk Art Masterpiece Unveiled Outside Timken Museum
San Diego Designates City Operations Building for Redevelopment
Marvel Introduces Treatz Truck at Comic-Con
Trial Begins for Man Charged with Attempted Murder of Officer
USS Pierre Completes Sea Trials as Final Independence-Class Ship
San Diego Engineer’s Remains to Be Launched into Space
San Diego City Council Caps Backyard Apartments to Tackle Overdevelopment
Carlsbad Renovation Merges Historic Charm with Modern Design
SDSU Baseball Seeks New Head Coach After Shaun Cole’s Departure
Pro-Housing Advocates Push for Reduced Lot Sizes in San Diego
Additional Resources
- San Diego Union Tribune: County Denies Plans for Sand Mine
- Google Search: Cottonwood Sand Mine
- Fox 5 San Diego: Leaders Revisit Sand Mine Proposal
- Wikipedia: Sand Mining
- CBS 8: Planning Commission Considers Sand Mining Project
- Encyclopedia Britannica: Sand
- San Diego Union Tribune: Cottonwood Sand Mine Vote
- Google News: Cottonwood Sand Mine
Author: STAFF HERE SAN DIEGO WRITER
SAN DIEGO STAFF WRITER The SAN DIEGO STAFF WRITER represents the experienced team at HERESanDiego.com, your go-to source for actionable local news and information in San Diego, San Diego County, and beyond. Specializing in "news you can use," we cover essential topics like product reviews for personal and business needs, local business directories, politics, real estate trends, neighborhood insights, and state news affecting the area—with deep expertise drawn from years of dedicated reporting and strong community input, including local press releases and business updates. We deliver top reporting on high-value events such as Comic-Con International, San Diego County Fair, and San Diego Pride Festival. Our coverage extends to key organizations like the San Diego Regional Chamber of Commerce and United Way of San Diego County, plus leading businesses in biotechnology, healthcare, and technology that power the local economy such as Qualcomm, Illumina, and Scripps Health. As part of the broader HERE network, including HEREAnaheim.com, HEREBeverlyHills.com, HERECostaMesa.com, HERECoronado.com, HEREHollywood.com, HEREHuntingtonBeach.com, HERELongBeach.com, HERELosAngeles.com, HEREMissionViejo.com, and HERESantaAna.com, we provide comprehensive, credible insights into California's dynamic landscape.
