News Summary
The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has upheld a ruling that the city of San Diego’s ban on yoga classes in public parks and beaches is unconstitutional. Declaring yoga a form of protected speech under the First Amendment, the court criticized the city’s lack of evidence linking the classes to public safety risks. The decision stems from legal challenges initiated by local yoga instructors who argued that the city’s restrictions violated their rights. The ruling raises significant questions about public access to spaces for community activities.
San Diego has faced a significant legal setback following the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals’ recent decision to uphold its ruling against the city’s ban on yoga classes in public parks and beaches, declaring the ban unconstitutional. The court concluded that yoga classes are protected by the First Amendment, emphasizing that San Diego officials had not provided sufficient evidence demonstrating a connection between these classes and public safety risks.
In its decision, the court affirmed an earlier ruling by a three-judge panel and unanimously rejected a petition from the city to rehear the case with a larger panel of judges. This ruling stems from concerns that the city’s restrictions on yoga classes imposed through an amended ordinance concerning street vendors violated the rights of individuals who lead these classes. The enforcement impacted gatherings of four or more people, crucial for many yoga instructors who conduct their sessions in public spaces.
The city of San Diego had argued that these yoga classes, even if offered for free or by donation, constituted commercial activity that required permits. Officials maintained that such measures were essential for preserving public access and preventing obstruction of pathways and scenic views within the parks. However, the court found that the city failed to demonstrate that yoga instruction posed any plausible threat to the public’s safety or enjoyment.
The legal challenges arose when yoga instructors Steven Hubbard, known as “NamaSteve,” and Amy Baack took action against the city, claiming their First Amendment rights were being infringed. Initially, a federal judge sided with the city. Still, the 9th Circuit ultimately determined that teaching yoga is a form of protected speech. The court pointed out that there was a lack of justification from the city regarding how these classes could lead to adverse public safety consequences.
Local residents had expressed dissatisfaction over what they perceived as excessive commercialization in some of their favorite parks and beaches, contributing to the city’s crackdown on outdoor yoga classes. Following the enforcement actions, Hubbard, who had taught free outdoor yoga in Palisades Park for nearly 20 years, found himself forced to transition some classes online via YouTube. After this pivot, his participants began gathering in parks to view his classes remotely, which resulted in additional citations.
Hubbard and Baack continue to seek damages through their ongoing litigation, including pursuing a parallel state lawsuit that argues yoga should be classified as an expressive activity under the California Constitution. Their legal representation criticized the city’s enforcement priorities, suggesting that resources would be better directed towards addressing genuine environmental crimes rather than focusing on yoga instruction.
Despite the ongoing legal battles and the latest ruling issued by the court, the city of San Diego has not publicly commented on the matter, leaving the future of yoga in public spaces in limbo. This ruling marks a critical moment in the ongoing dialogue surrounding public access to parks and the balance between community activities and regulatory oversight.
In summary, the 9th Circuit’s decision reinforces the notion that yoga classes are an expression of free speech and suggests that prohibitive measures taken by the city lacked legitimate reasoning. The case brings to light the complexities surrounding public space usage, while it also highlights the ongoing tension between city regulations and individuals’ rights to gather and express themselves through activities like yoga. As the legal proceedings continue, the outcomes may set important precedents regarding similar public activities throughout the nation.
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
HERE Resources
San Diego’s Weekend of Fun and Culture
San Diego City Council Adopts Coastal Resilience Plan
Naturally San Diego Transforms Coffee + Convos Event
Spoke Art Returns to San Diego Comic-Con
San Diego to Host Inaugural Wellness Week Celebration
San Diego to Host Premier Wellness Week
San Diego Officials Urge Fireworks Safety Amid Fourth of July
San Diego County Fair Celebrates Pets with Summer Pet-tacular Theme
San Diego’s Legal Battle Over Free Yoga Classes
Weekend Events in San Diego Celebrating Heritage and Family
Additional Resources
- Fox 5 San Diego
- Wikipedia: First Amendment to the United States Constitution
- San Diego Union Tribune
- Google Search: San Diego yoga classes ban
- NBC San Diego
- Google Scholar: San Diego yoga classes First Amendment
- 10 News
- Encyclopedia Britannica: Free speech
- Times of San Diego
- Google News: San Diego yoga classes legal
Author: STAFF HERE SAN DIEGO WRITER
SAN DIEGO STAFF WRITER The SAN DIEGO STAFF WRITER represents the experienced team at HERESanDiego.com, your go-to source for actionable local news and information in San Diego, San Diego County, and beyond. Specializing in "news you can use," we cover essential topics like product reviews for personal and business needs, local business directories, politics, real estate trends, neighborhood insights, and state news affecting the area—with deep expertise drawn from years of dedicated reporting and strong community input, including local press releases and business updates. We deliver top reporting on high-value events such as Comic-Con International, San Diego County Fair, and San Diego Pride Festival. Our coverage extends to key organizations like the San Diego Regional Chamber of Commerce and United Way of San Diego County, plus leading businesses in biotechnology, healthcare, and technology that power the local economy such as Qualcomm, Illumina, and Scripps Health. As part of the broader HERE network, including HEREAnaheim.com, HEREBeverlyHills.com, HERECostaMesa.com, HERECoronado.com, HEREHollywood.com, HEREHuntingtonBeach.com, HERELongBeach.com, HERELosAngeles.com, HEREMissionViejo.com, and HERESantaAna.com, we provide comprehensive, credible insights into California's dynamic landscape.
