News Summary
Residents of Middletown protested against a proposed 14-story apartment building set to include 161 units, expressing concerns over safety, traffic, and community character. The protest highlighted fears about the projected pricing of the units, their suitability for families, and potential violations of FAA height restrictions. Community members urged for responsible growth metrics aligning with local needs while advocating for affordable housing solutions. Amidst the backlash, the developer has paused the project for further dialogue with locals.
Middletown residents protested on Saturday against a proposed 14-story apartment building that would include 161 units at the intersection of Columbia Street. The building, proposed by ELDA Developments, has drawn significant opposition from the community concerning its impact on local safety, traffic, and the existing neighborhood character.
The protest attracted numerous residents who voiced their collective concerns, emphasizing that the proposed building does not fit within the current community aesthetic. One of the leading voices against the development, local homeowner Scott Case, argued that the building’s height would overshadow nearby homes. The site, currently occupied by one single-family home and a two-story apartment building with three affordable units, is located in the dense 3600 block of Columbia Street.
Substantial opposition arose from the project’s alignment with San Diego’s Complete Communities initiative, which mandates only six affordable units for such developments. Community members expressed that this number does not sufficiently address the local demand for affordable housing. The proposed units are mainly studios and one-bedroom apartments, approximately 80% of the total, which critics argue are inadequate for family living.
Pricing for the units is projected to range from $3,000 for studios to $10,000 for penthouse apartments, according to an investment brochure published by ELDA Developments. Such pricing raises further questions about the affordability of the offerings in light of the community’s needs.
The proposal also includes 70 parking spaces, a factor that has drawn criticism from local residents who already face parking challenges. Protesters highlighted traffic concerns that could arise from the project’s impact on the narrow streets surrounding the proposed site. There are apprehensions about potential complications for fire lanes and the accessibility for customers visiting nearby local businesses.
Participants in the rally wore banners and chanted slogans such as “responsible growth not corporate greed,” illustrating their desire for manageable development that prioritizes the community’s well-being. Opponents of the development emphasized their advocacy for responsible growth, distancing themselves from the “Not In My Backyard” (NIMBY) label often used against critics of new developments.
A counter-protestor, part of the “Yes In My Backyard” (YIMBY) movement, argued in favor of the new housing developments as necessary to support a diverse community. However, the overwhelming sentiment at the rally was one of caution about the drastic changes that a 14-story structure could bring to Middletown.
Community members also expressed fears regarding the safety implications of the building’s proximity to a seismic hazard area and the airport. Concerns were raised that the development might violate FAA height restrictions. Residents are still awaiting clarity, as current plans have been halted, with the developer yet to release revised proposals following the public outcry.
The city’s Development Services Department currently has an open application for grading on the site. A geologist from the department has indicated that the geotechnical evaluation lacked evidence of the absence of active fault lines within a 50-foot radius, potentially complicating the development further.
In response to the backlash from the community, ELDA Developments’ CEO stated that the company had paused the development to foster dialogue with local residents and to reassess the project in light of the expressed opposition. The proposal remains under significant scrutiny, with ongoing discussions anticipated as the community and the developer navigate the complexities surrounding the project.
In summary, the proposed 14-story apartment building in Middletown is facing mounting opposition due to concerns regarding its impact on affordable housing, community character, traffic, parking, and overall safety. As the developer considers revisions to the proposal, community members remain vigilant in advocating for their needs and values.
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
HERE Resources
Additional Resources
- Times of San Diego: Developer Middletown 14-Story Apartments Community Pushback
- Wikipedia: Middletown, San Diego
- Fox 5 San Diego: Residents Protest Proposed 14-Story Apartment Complex
- Google Search: Middletown apartments protest
- NBC San Diego: Concerns Over Middletown High Rise
- Encyclopedia Britannica: Apartment
- Times of San Diego: Protesters 14-Story Apartments Middletown NIMBY YIMBY
