News Summary
The San Diego Unified School District Board of Education is set to review updates to its Restorative Discipline Policy, aiming to foster student accountability while reducing punitive measures. The revisions come after community feedback, with the district noting decreased suspension rates since the original policy’s adoption in 2020. However, some parents express concerns about maintaining safety for students. The updates will be implemented starting in the 2025–26 school year, with staff training beginning this summer. The outcome of the vote will be closely monitored by both supporters and critics.
San Diego – The San Diego Unified School District Board of Education is preparing to vote on updates to its Restorative Discipline Policy during a meeting scheduled for Tuesday. The board’s revisions aim to enhance student accountability and support while moving away from reliance on punitive measures. This revised policy continues to emphasize restorative practices, promoting community-building and responsibility among students.
The planned updates to the policy come in response to feedback gathered from students, families, and educators since the policy was first adopted in 2020. The district has noted a steady decrease in expulsions since implementing the original policy, with the suspension rate recorded at just 2.5% last year. This figure is significantly lower than those of other large urban school districts in California, including Long Beach Unified and Fresno Unified.
Key district officials have reported that the decline in suspension and expulsion rates does not negatively impact overall student safety or accountability. The intention behind the updates is to maintain accountability while providing a nurturing environment that fosters community involvement. Starting in the 2025–26 school year, the district plans to implement these updates, with staff training slated to begin this summer.
However, the upcoming school board meeting may not be without contention. Some parents are expected to voice concerns regarding the revisions, highlighting what they feel are flaws in the policy based on incidents reported at Standley Middle School. Critics argue that the policy, as it stands, allows students who repeatedly break the rules to return to schools, potentially creating unsafe conditions for their peers. In response to these concerns, a group of parents has formed an advocacy organization called SDParents4Safety, which is pushing for a reassessment of the discipline policy.
The original policy was designed to combat the disproportionate effects of exclusionary discipline practices on students of color. It aims to replace traditional punitive responses with interventions like counseling and community service, focusing instead on keeping students in school while addressing behavioral issues. The goal is for consequences to be intentionally designed to encourage learning of pro-social skills, rather than purely administering punishment.
Under the current guidelines, decisions regarding expulsion require the approval of the board of education, establishing a structured approach to managing severe behavioral problems. This process underscores the district’s efforts to handle discipline with consideration for the educational and social development of all students.
As the Board of Education prepares to vote on the updated Restorative Discipline Policy, the outcome will be closely watched by both supporters and critics who have vested interests in the safety and well-being of students within the district. The discussions and decisions made in this meeting are anticipated to have significant implications for the school’s disciplinary framework moving forward.
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
HERE Resources
Additional Resources
- San Diego Unified Seeks to Strengthen Restorative Discipline Policy
- Wikipedia: Restorative Justice
- San Diego Unified Parents to Share Concerns Over Restorative Discipline Policy
- Google Search: Restorative Discipline Policy San Diego Unified
- It Takes More Than Just Punishment to Repair Harm
- Google Scholar: Restorative Justice in Education
- University of San Diego Launches Masters Program in Restorative Justice
- Encyclopedia Britannica: Discipline
- Parents Fear Restorative Discipline Policy Will Turn District into Statistic of School Violence
- Google News: Restorative Justice Policy Criticism
