News Summary
San Diego Mayor Todd Gloria and City Councilmember Stephen Whitburn are adamantly opposing the U.S. Navy’s plan to rename the USNS Harvey Milk, a ship named after the significant gay rights leader. As tensions rise during Pride Month, this controversy highlights the ongoing struggle for LGBTQ+ visibility and respect within the military. Gloria aims to ensure that the ship retains its original name, asserting that renaming it would diminish the contributions of LGBTQ+ veterans, especially given that Harvey Milk served in the Navy before becoming an influential advocate for equal rights.
San Diego leaders are opposing the U.S. Navy’s plan to rename the USNS Harvey Milk, a fleet replenishment oiler named after the prominent gay rights leader and Navy veteran. Mayor Todd Gloria and City Councilmember Stephen Whitburn convened a press conference to voice their objections, amidst rising tensions due to the proposed name change. Currently, the Navy Secretary John Phelan has established a small team to consider renaming options, with a new name expected to be announced within the month.
According to U.S. officials, no decision has yet been made regarding the new name for the ship. An internal memo noted that the objectives behind the renaming are to align the military with the priorities of former President Trump, particularly the perceived need for a resurgence of a more traditional “warrior culture.” Mayor Gloria firmly stated that he intends for the ship to retain its original name, regardless of directives from Washington, D.C.
The controversy surrounding the USNS Harvey Milk takes on added significance as it coincides with Pride Month, a time dedicated to celebrating the LGBTQ+ community and their contributions to society. Councilmember Whitburn argued that the move to rename the ship represents an attempt to render LGBTQ+ veterans “invisible” once again, undermining their contributions and sacrifices.
Members of the California Veterans Board also expressed their concerns over the proposed renaming, with remarks focusing on issues of trust and respect within the military community. Harvey Milk himself served in the Navy for four years before being discharged due to his sexual orientation. He later emerged as one of the first openly gay elected officials in the United States, making his legacy even more poignant in today’s discussions about LGBTQ+ rights.
The USNS Harvey Milk was officially christened in November 2021 and has been operating under the Military Sealift Command since 2024. Its name has been celebrated as both a tribute to Harvey Milk’s legacy and as a symbol of inclusion and progress within the military. Efforts to rename the vessel have raised alarms, suggesting that such actions could reverse advances made toward recognizing LGBTQ+ individuals in the armed forces.
Several observers, including California Governor Gavin Newsom, have condemned the proposal, linking it to a broader issue of respect for the values fought for by veterans. The Biden administration’s past actions to change Navy ship names for those associated with the Confederacy have contextualized the current efforts to rename the Harvey Milk as potentially politically motivated and contradictory to the administration’s commitments to inclusivity.
Prominent LGBTQ+ rights activists, including Nicole Murray-Ramirez, shared their disbelief regarding the renaming of a ship dedicated to a historical figure who fought for equal rights. Many see this potential renaming as an erasure of history and as a significant setback for LGBTQ+ recognition.
Critics argue that the consequences of the name change go beyond symbolism, posing concerns about crew morale and unity among ship members. They stress that renaming such vessels may incite divisions among crew and impact operational effectiveness. Furthermore, historians have pointed out that altering ship names contradicts advancements in narratives that focus on diversity and inclusion.
At the press conference, community members expressed emotional investment, rallying against the renaming efforts. Multiple speakers highlighted the significance of honoring those who have worked to expand rights rather than diminish them. Advocacy for maintaining the name of the USNS Harvey Milk is framed not just as a defense of a name, but as a broader stand against the ongoing marginalization of LGBTQ+ individuals in society.
As events develop regarding the USNS Harvey Milk and the Navy’s renaming plans, the tensions between inclusivity, representation, and historical accountability continue to unfold, keeping the discussion in the public eye as Pride Month emphasizes LGBTQ+ rights and visibility across the nation.
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
HERE Resources
Additional Resources
- CBS 8 News
- Wikipedia: Harvey Milk
- NBC San Diego
- Google Search: USNS Harvey Milk
- San Diego Union-Tribune
- Encyclopedia Britannica: Harvey Milk
- Times of San Diego
- Google News: Renaming USNS Harvey Milk
